Emily Doolittle, Buddhamas P. Kriengwatana, Ruedi Nager, Alex South, Martin Ullrich
Presented by Buddhamas P. Kriengwatana at the 31st Conference of the International Society for Anthrozoology, 7-9 July 2022.
Background The last two decades have seen a flurry of scientific publications investigating whether playing music to captive animals has measurable effects, e.g. improving their quality of life. These studies are typically conducted by scientists who are not themselves musicians, and who have little knowledge of the historical and socio-cultural forces that have shaped the various musics of the world, nor of the centuries-long history of philosophical and practical explorations of the relationship between animal songs and human music. Though these studies are well intended, insufficient understanding of the music stimuli being used leads to difficulties addressing hypotheses about why music could be beneficial for animals, and inappropriate conclusions about what animals’ responses towards music imply.
Objectives Our goal is to demonstrate that involvement of disciplines in the humanities such as musicology, history, and philosophy, are crucial to significantly advance the research being done in ecology, ethology, zoology, and welfare sciences on how music affects animals. A better understanding of the workings of the
music itself, the socio-cultural circumstances and values that influenced its creation, and species-typical musicalities, is necessary for helping scientists to 1) select the most appropriate music to test key hypotheses, leading to more refined research questions; 2) consider ethical implications when interpreting animals’ responses to music; 3) understand the cultural biases that are involved in directing, and/or dominating this line of research.
Methods We apply an interdisciplinary and methodically pluralistic approach, combining scholarly music analysis and discourse analysis with empirical testing of scientific hypotheses.
Implications The capacities underlying music production and perception may have biological origins shared to different degrees in other animals, but music is a cultural product. Thus, research on how music affects animals needs to take into account biological and cultural factors.